Current:Home > ScamsFlorida Gov. DeSantis discriminated against Black voters by dismantling congressional district, lawyer argues -Infinite Edge Capital
Florida Gov. DeSantis discriminated against Black voters by dismantling congressional district, lawyer argues
View
Date:2025-04-13 19:22:18
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis racially discriminated against Black voters by endorsing a congressional map that scattered them across four North Florida districts won by white Republicans and erased a seat held by a Black Democrat, attorneys for voters’ groups argued Tuesday in federal court.
The opening day of a trial before a three-judge panel saw attorneys for Common Cause, the NAACP, Fair Districts Now, and individual voters press for reasons behind DeSantis’ drive to eliminate the Tallahassee to Jacksonville, Florida, district held by U.S. Rep. Al Lawson.
"The governor was undeterred in his mission to eliminate the Black opportunity district in North Florida," said Gregory Baker, an attorney for the plaintiffs.
DeSantis pushed the congressional map on the Florida Legislature, vetoing last year two maps approved by lawmakers – one which created a Black-leaning district confined to Duval County and a backup plan that retained the east-west seat held by Lawson.
The GOP-dominated Legislature approved the DeSantis plan when called back to the Capitol for a special session. Republicans won 20 of Florida’s 28 congressional districts in last fall’s elections, a four-seat pick-up for the GOP which helped the party regain control of the U.S. House.
Called as the first witness in the trial, expected to last more than a week, was J. Alex Kelly, the governor’s chief mapmaker and currently, his acting chief-of-staff.
Kelly said DeSantis viewed recreating an east-west North Florida district favorable to a Black candidate as an illegal racial gerrymander, even though it had been first formed by the Florida Supreme Court in 2015.
Kelly said DeSantis believed that the district violated the federal constitution’s equal protection clause, essentially favoring Black voters over white voters.
"He never once commented on eliminating a Black opportunity district," Kelly said about what he called the governor’s "race-neutral" strategy, under questioning from plaintiffs’ attorney Gregory Diskant.
"He asked me to draw a compliant map."
Court got it wrong, staff chief says
Diskant pointed out that while the governor may have his opinion about the law, the state Supreme Court had ordered the district put in place, a move which seemingly carried more weight.
“The Florida Supreme Court got it wrong,” Kelly testified.
One of the judges, M. Casey Rodgers, an appointee of former Republican President George W. Bush, also struggled to learn how DeSantis determined that the Tallahassee to Jacksonville district violated the equal protection clause, a provision added to the U.S. Constitution following the Civil War largely to protect Black citizens.
“As interpreted by what court?” Rodgers asked Kelly about DeSantis’ conclusion. “Is there a court decision the governor cites that agrees with him on the equal protection clause?”
Kelly acknowledged there was no such ruling.
But Mohammad Jazil, attorney for the state, echoed the argument, accusing the voters’ groups of “turning equal protection on its head.”
GOP lawmakers concede to DeSantisSpecial session: Florida lawmakers heeding Gov. DeSantis' demand for new congressional map, enraging opponents
DeSantis touts redistricting during bid for GOP nomination
DeSantis, during his faltering campaign for the Republican presidential nomination, has credited his actions with giving his party command of Congress.
Now, though, the governor is struggling to keep those Republican-friendly congressional boundaries in place.
The map has already been ruled unconstitutional by Leon County Circuit Judge J. Lee Marsh, who rejected the DeSantis administration’s contention that the state constitution’s prohibition against weakening or eliminating minority-leaning districts conflicted with the U.S. Constitution’s equal protection clause.
Marsh’s ruling is now before the 1st District Court of Appeal. The DCA surprisingly took control of the case despite agreements from both the state and plaintiffs, which include Black Voters Matter and the League of Women Voters, that any appeal should go straight to the Florida Supreme Court.
Amid growing concerns about a potential delay in deciding the state case, this week’s federal trial possibly could lead to a swifter outcome on whether state lawmakers must redraw the congressional map and restore Lawson’s old Tallahassee to Jacksonville district before next year’s elections.
Lawson has said he would consider being a candidate if the district was restored.
Fear of foot-dragging
Plaintiffs fear the 1st DCA, whose judges were appointed by Republican governors, and the Florida Supreme Court, where five of the seven members were picked by DeSantis, could take their time deciding the case.
Even if the map is ruled invalid, timing could leave it in place through the 2024 elections, when Republicans’ narrow control of the U.S. House is again at stake. Florida’s four-seat GOP gain last year was the party’s biggest improvement in the nation.
U.S. Supreme Court rulings this summer may have bolstered the claims of voters’ groups suing over Florida’s congressional map.
Even as the trial opened Tuesday in Tallahassee’s U.S. District Court, justices again acted, refusing Alabama’s request to reinstate a congressional map drawn by the Republican-held Legislature which had only one majority-Black district.
Instead, it’s likely that a new map will be in place before next year’s elections.
Justices in a 5-4 ruling in June said that Alabama lawmakers had denied Black voters a reasonable chance to elect a second U.S. representative of their choice.
While limited to Alabama, the latest decision will likely affect other states, including Florida, Louisiana, Georgia, and Texas, where courtroom clashes over race and redistricting are underway.
John Kennedy is a reporter in the USA TODAY Network’s Florida Capital Bureau. He can be reached at jkennedy2@gannett.com, or on Twitter at @JKennedyReport
veryGood! (5)
Related
- 'Kraven the Hunter' spoilers! Let's dig into that twisty ending, supervillain reveal
- Matthew McConaughey and Camila Alves' Kids Steal the Show at Paris Fashion Week
- Sleek and shiny torch for Paris Olympics unveiled with carbon footprint in mind and a year to go
- Finland offering free trips after being named world's happiest country six years in a row
- Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
- Pregnant The Ultimatum Star April Marie Reveals Sex of First Baby With Cody Cooper
- 14 Fashionable Finds From H&M That Look Double the Price
- Kim Kardashian Jokes That Son Saint Is “Not as Cute as I Thought” After He Pulled This Move
- Trump wants to turn the clock on daylight saving time
- Heather Rae El Moussa Teases Her Future on Selling Sunset
Ranking
- Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
- Russia to deploy tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus, on Ukraine's northern border, Putin says
- Heather Rae El Moussa Teases Her Future on Selling Sunset
- Emma Heming-Willis Sends Emotional Plea to Paparazzi After Bruce Willis’ Dementia Diagnosis
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- Prince William makes surprise visit to soldiers near Poland's border with Ukraine
- China's Xi to visit Putin in Moscow as Beijing seeks larger global role
- American held hostage since 2016 in West Africa released
Recommendation
Opinion: Gianni Infantino, FIFA sell souls and 2034 World Cup for Saudi Arabia's billions
France strikes and protests over pension changes heat up as Macron defends his controversial reforms
Amazon Vacation Shop: 17 Affordable Travel Essentials for Your Next Trip
Ray J Calls Off Divorce From Princess Love Again
Rylee Arnold Shares a Long
Kylie Jenner & Khloe Kardashian Bring Kids to Friend's Birthday Party That's Straight Out of a Fairytale
The mysteries of Johannes Vermeer
Below Deck Preview Teases an Awkward Love Triangle Between Ben, Camille and New Stew Leigh-Ann